This research project material is available: WRONGFUL TERMINATION OF CONTRACTS OF EMPLOYMENT IN NIGERIA: A CASE FOR REINSTATEMENT OF PRIVATE EMPLOYEES



Download Complete Research Material on WRONGFUL TERMINATION OF CONTRACTS OF EMPLOYMENT IN NIGERIA: A CASE FOR REINSTATEMENT OF PRIVATE EMPLOYEES



Project Category: Type: Project Materials | Format: Ms Word | Attribute: Documentation Only | Pages: 98 Pages | Chapters: 1-5 chapters | Price: ₦ 3,000.00


Call or whatsapp: +2347063298784 or email: info@allprojectmaterials.com.



WRONGFUL TERMINATION OF CONTRACTS OF EMPLOYMENT IN NIGERIA: A CASE FOR REINSTATEMENT OF PRIVATE EMPLOYEES



TABLE OF CONTENTS

Title page            -                  -                  -                  -                  i

Approval page   -                  -                  -                  -                  ii      

Dedication          -                  -                  -                  -                  iii

Acknowledgement                -                  -                  -                  iv

Abstract              -                  -                  -                  -                  v

Table of Contents                  -                  -                  -                  vi

Table of Cases                       -                  -                  -                  ix

Table of Statutes                    -                  -                  -                  xii

Abbreviations                        -                  -                  -                  xiv

 

CHAPTER ONE:        CONTRACTS OF EMPLOYMENT: MEANING AND NATURE

 

1.1            Introduction                 -                  -                  -                  1

1.2            Meaning and Nature of Contract of Employment              1

1.2.1    Offer and Acceptance                     -                  -                  2       

1.2.2    Consideration              -                  -                  -                  3

1.2.3    Intention to Create legal relation  -                  -                  4

1.2.4    Capacity                       -                  -                  -                  4

1.3            Parties to a Contract of Employment     -        -                  6

1.3.1    Employer                      -                  -                  -                  7

1.3.2    Employee                     -                  -                  -                  8

1.4            Independent Contractor                           -        -                  8

1.5            Why an Employee needs Protection       -        -                  9

1.6            Conclusion                             -                  -                  -                  11

CHAPTER TWO:  TERMINATION OF CONTRACT OF

   PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT

 

2.1            Introduction                           -                  -        -                  13

2.2            Under Public Employment            -                  -                  13

2.3            Different methods of Termination of Contract

of Employment                      -                  -        -                  15

2.3.1    Termination by Operation of Law                             -                  16

2.3.2     Termination by Intention of Parties                -                  20

2.3.3     Summary Dismissal                      -                  -                  27

2.3.4    Conclusion                             -                  -                  -                  30

 

CHAPTER THREE:    WRONGFUL TERMINATION OF CONTRACT OF PRIVATE EMPLOYMENT

 

3.1            Introduction                           -                  -        -                  33

3.2            Wrongful Termination of Contract of Private 

Employment                          -                  -        -                  34

3.2.1    Lack of Just Cause                 -                  -        -                  36

3.2.2    Wrong Procedure                  -                  -        -                  42

3.2.3    Lack of Proper Notice                     -                  -                  46

3.2.4    Breach of the Rules of Natural Justice              -                  51

3.2.5    Conclusion                             -                  -                  -                  55

CHAPTER FOUR:      REINSTATEMENT

4.1            Introduction                           -                            -                  58

4.2            Reinstatement              -                  -                  -                  59

4.3            Conclusion                                       -                  -                  70

CHAPTER FIVE:   OBSERVATIONS, SUGGESTIONS

   AND CONCLUSION

5.1            Introduction                 -                  -                  -                  72

5.2            Observation and suggestions                  -                  -                  73

5.3            Conclusion                             -                  -                  -                  82

Bibliography                         -                  -                  -                  86


TABLE OF CASES

 

1.                 AFOLABI v. POLYMERA IND. NIG. LTD.

          (1967) N.SC.C. 158               -        -        -        -        -        2

2.                 AFRIBANK v. NWANZE (1998) 6 NWLR

(pt 553), 283       -        -        -        -        -        -        -        39

3.                 AKINLADE FALOMO v. LAGOS STATE PUBLIC

          SERVICE (COMMISSION -         -        -        -        -        32

         

4.                 BANKOLE v. NBC  (1968)2 All NLR 371-    -        -        18

5.                 BRAVE v. CONDLER (1895)2 QB 293 --       -        -        10

6.                 CALLIL v. CARBOLIC SMOKE BALL CO.

          (1893)1 GB 256   -        -        -        -        -        -        -        1

7.                 CHUKWUMAH v. S.P.D.C. (1993) 4 NWLR

          pt 568, 512 -        -        -        -        -        -        -        -        37

8.                 COLEMAN v. MAGNET JOINERY LTD

          (1975) 1 CR 46    -        -        -        -        -        -        -        34

9.                 CONDOR v. BARON KNIGHTS LTD.

          (1966) 1 WLR 87          -        -        -        -        -        -        -        11

10.     COWEY v. LIBERIAN OPERATIONS LTD

          (1966) 2  lloyd’S Rep. 45      -        -        -        -        -        8

11.            CURRIE v. MISA (1875) L.R. 10  -        -        -        -        2

12.            DE FRANCESCO v. BARNUM (1890) 45

          CH.D. 430, 438  -        -        -        -        -        -        -        39

13.            DON EDWARD ADEJUMO v. UCH BOARD OF MANAGEMENT (1997)2 UILR 145   -        -        -        13,22

14.            DR. BABATUNDE OWOLABI SANGUNUGA v. AKINWU MOTOR & ANOR. (1980) decided on 7th March   -        48

 

15.            EJEGI v. AGIP NIGERIA LTD. (1968) 4 A.C. 99   -        39

16.            EWEROMI v. A.C.B. (1978)4 A.C. 99   -        -        -        29

17.            GEORGE NICOL v. ELECTRICITY CORPORATION 

          (1965) LLR 261   -        -        -        -        -        -        -        13

18.            GOULD v. STAURT (1896) A.C. 375   -        -        -        14

19.            GWAGOH v. BENDEL STATE HOSPITAL

          MANAGEMENT BOARD.          -        -        -        -        45

20.            HALSBURY’S LAWS OF ENGLAND -        -        -        12

21.            HALL v. PARSON (1978)1 CH. 14, 69 -        -        -        28

22.            HAROID FIELDING LTD. v. MANSI (1974)1

          RLR 79       -        -        -        -        -        -        -        -        4

23.            HART v. MILITARY GOVERNOR, RIVER STATE

          NO. 17 OF 1984 -        -        -        -        -        -        -        26

24.            HEYMAN v. DROWINS LTD. (1942) 1 All

          ER 337, 341                  -        -        -        -        -        -        33

25.            HILL v. C.A. PARSON AND CO. LTD. (1971)3

          ALL ER 1347 (CA)      -        -        -        -        -        -        38

26.            INTERNATIONAL DRILLING COMPANY (NIG)

          LTD. v. AJIJALA (1976) 2 S.C. 115 P.9, 584  -        -        48

27.            IREM v. OBUBRA DISTRICT COUNCIL (1960)5

          F.S.C. 24    -        -        -        -        -        -        -        -        16

 

28.            JOSIAH LAOYE v. CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION

          (1989)2 NNLR 652      -        -        -        -        -        -        32

29.            KONDA v. GOVT. OF THE FEDERATION OF

          MALAYA (1962) A.C. 322           -        -        -        -        31

30.            LAW LONDON CHRONICLE LTD. (1959)2

          ALL E.R. 285               -        -        -        -        -        -        23

31.            MCCLELLAND v. NORTHERN IRELAND

          GENERAL HEALTH SERVICES BOARD (1957)1

          WLR 594 (HL)   -        -        -        -        -        -        -        37

32.            MOBIL OIL NIG. LTD. v. AKINFOSILE

          (1969) NMLR 217       -        -        -        -        -        -        37, 48

33.            MOELLER v. MONNIER CONSTRUCTION

          (NIG) LTD. (1961) 1 ALL NLR 167                -        -        16

34.            MORTON SUNDOUR FABRICS LTD. v. SHAW

          (1966)2 KLRI 25 -        -        -        -        -        -        -        27

35.            N.A.L.G.O. v. BOLTON CORPORATION (1943)

          A.C. 166              -        -        -        -        -        -        -        5

36.            NDILL v. OKARA AND SONS (1976) 11 S.C. 211-       26

37.            NOKES v. DONCASTER AMALGAMENTED

          COLLINERISES LTD.         (1946) A.C. 1014          -        -        10

38.            NUNMINK v. COSTAIN DREDGING LTD.

          (1960) LLR 90     -        -        -        -        -        -        -        13

39.            O.A. MARTINS v. BRAITHWAITE AND CO. LTD.

           (1972) 2 CH. 72. 52              -        -        -        -        -        15

40.            ODIASE v. AUCHI POLYTECHNIC (1998)4

          NWLR pt. 546             -        -        -        -        -        -        18

41.            OLANIYAN v. UNIVERSITY OF LAGOS (1969)2

          ALL E.R. 216               -        -        -        -        -        -        25,40

42.            OLANIYAN (SUPRA) 1985                  -        -        -         26, 29, 35

43.            OLAREWAJU v. AFRIBANK (2001) 13

          NWLR pt. 731, 691               -        -        -        -        -        37

44.            OLATUNBOSUN v. MISER COUNCIL (1988)3

          NMLR pt. 80, 89, 49             -        -        -        -        -        31

45.            OSISANYA v. AFRIBANK (NIG) PLC 

          (2007)6 NWLR p.9 565        -        -        -        -        -        36

46.            OYEDELE v. L.U.T.H. (1990)6 NWLR

          pt. 155, Pg. 199  -        -        -        -        -        -        -        45

47.            PEPPER v. WEBB (1959)2 ER 285.                  -        -        24

48.            PROVINCIAL TRANSPORT SERVICES v. STATE

          INDUSTRIAL COURT AIR 1963 SC 114, 116.       -        38

49.     ROAD TRANSPORT INDUSTRY TAINING

          BOARD  v. ONGARO (1943) A.C. 166          -        -        -        4

50.            ROSE AND FRANK v. CROMPTON (1923)2

          K.B. 261     -        -        -        -        -        -        -        -        2

51.            SINCLAIR v. NEIGHBOUR (1966)3 ALL ER 988 -        13

52.            STANGE (SW) LTD. v. MANN -        -        -        -        8

53.            STOCCO v. MAJA (1964)2 ALL NLR 35      -        -        13

54.            TIMBERS v. PLYWOOD LTD. (1966) 1 ALL

          NLR 87      -        -        -        -        -        -        -        -        23

55.            VINE v. NATIONAL DREK LABOUR BOARD

          (1956)1 ALL E.R. pg. 8.        -        -        -        -        -        33

TABLE OF STATUTES

 

The 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria:

 

S.  33 (1)              -        -        -        -        -        -        30, 35, 46

 

S.  36 (1)              -        -        -        -        -        -        30, 35, 46

 

The Nigerian Labour Act Cap. L1 LFN 2004:

S. 2             -        -        -        -        -        -        -        9, 44

S. 7             -        -        -        -        -        -        -        43

S. 9 (7)                 -        -        -        -        -        -        -        9, 21

S. 10 (1)     -        -        -        -        -        -        -        4

S. 11 (1)     -        -        -        -        -        -        -        20, 30

S. 15           -        -        -        -        -        -        -        11

S. 19           -        -        -        -        -        -        -        3

S. 20           -        -        -        -        -        -        -        14, 15

S. 59 (8)     -        -        -        -        -        -        -        3

S. 61 (3)     -        -        -        -        -        -        -        3

S. 91           -        -        -        -        -        -        -        3

ABBREVIATIONS

1.       N.W.L.R.             -        Nigerian Weekly Law Report

2.       N.M.L.R.             -        Nigeria Monthly Law Report

3.       N.S.C.C.              -        Nigerian Supreme Court Cases

4.       C.C.H.C.J.           -        Certified Copies of High Court

Judgment

5.       All N.L.R.           -        All Nigerian Law Reports

6.       F.S.C.                   -        Federal Supreme Court

7.       H.L.                     -        House of Lord Report

8.       A.C.                     -        Appeal Cases

9.       Ch. App.             -        Chancery Appeal

10.     Q.B.D.                 -        Queens Bench Division

11.     K.B.                     -        Kings Bench

12.     L.T.R.                  -        Law Times Report

13.     Ch. D.                 -        Chancery Division

14.     S.C.                      -        Supreme Court

15.     N.C.L.R.              -        Nigerian Constitution Law Report

16.     W.N.L.R.            -        Western Nigerian Law Report

17.     N.N.L.R.             -        Northern Nigerian Law Report

18.     All E.R.               -        All England Report.

19.     E.R.                      -        English Report

20.     Exch.                   -        Exchanger

21.     N.L.J.                   -        Nigerian Law Journal

22.     L.L.R.                   -        Lagos Law Report.

23.     W.L.R.                 -        Weekly Law Report

24.     U.I.L.R.               -        University of Ife Law Report

25.     E.N.L.R.              -        Eastern Nigerian Law Report

26.     S.                          -        Section

27.     pp.                       -        Page

 

 


CHAPTER ONE

 

CONTRACTS OF EMPLOYMENT: MEANING AND NATURE

 

1.1     Introduction

A contract of employment is an agreement between two or more persons relationship established by contract, creating an obligation to do a particular thing in a contract of employment.

1.2     Meaning and Nature

The nature of contract of employment is the relationship between an employer and his employee comes into existence as a result of a contract between them generally referred to a contract of service, which means any agreement whether oral or written, expressed or implied, where by one person agrees to employ another as a worker and that other person agrees to serve the employer as a worker as contained in Labour Act[1]

Generally, the contract of employment is an off-shoot of our general law of contract where the essential ingredients of the contract must be found present before it’s enforceability.

1.2.1  Offer and Acceptance

In every contract of an employment, there is a meeting of the minds of the parties before the enforceability of the contract. That is to say, an offer must be made by one party called (offeror) as in Callil v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co.[2] and the acceptance of the offer by the other party called (offeree) as in the case of Afolabi v. Polymera Ind. Nig. Ltd.[3]  This principle of offer and acceptance entails freedom of both parties to offer and accept unconditionally the terms of employment.

1.2.2  Consideration

In a contract of employment, where there is an offer and acceptance by both parties to the contract of services, there must be a consideration to furnished the contract, describing some rights, interest, profit or benefit occurring to one party or some fore-bearance detriment, loss or responsibility given, suffered or undertaking by the other.[4] The above explanation was illustrated in the case of Currie v. Misa[5]  Therefore, consideration in the contract of employment is the salary and other fringe benefits which an employee earns on one part and services which an employer receives on the other part.

 

1.2.3  Intention to create Legal Relation

The relationship between an employer and employee is established by contract. Where both parties agreed on the terms of the contract of employment, creating a common intention of both parties to enter into a legal obligation that is contained in the employment agreement Rose and Frank v. Crompton[6] 

1.2.4  Capacity

The law is settled that parties to a contract of employment must possess the capacity of contract as recognized by law at common law.  Certain categories of persons namely; infants, mentally infirm and disordered person and drunkards in certain circumstance are incapable of entering into a contract.[7]  This has been specified in our statute Nigeria Labour Act 2004.

In the case of an infant, the law forbids to engage a person (child) below the age of sixteen years from entering into any contract of employment except that of an apprenticeship.  But the Act provides in Section 19(1) of the Labour Act 2004 that a child under twelve years of age can be employed only by a member of his family and even then, subject to his rights, agricultural, horticultural or domestic work approved by the Minister of Labour as stated in Section 91(1) (a) Labour Act.

However, Section 59 of the Act is an exception apparently to enable a youth receive his education in a technical school. In respect of working on a ship in general, Section 61 (3) of the Act provides that even when the non-adult is allowed to be so employed, he can work only on a vessel in which only members of the same class are employed.

Under Section 59 of the Act, the Minister of Labour has power to notify an employer in writing that the kind of work in which a young person is employed is injurious to his health, immoral or otherwise unsuitable.

Finally on mentally infirm and disordered person are persons who are insane, unsound minds incapable of being conscious and rational thinking on the obligation of the terms of the contract of employment.

1.3     Parties to a Contract of Employment

A contract of employment or services is entered into and enforceable by the employers and the employees, which automatically forms or constitute the major parties to a contract of employment in Nigeria Labour Law.

A person who is in a contract of employment with another cannot be transferred to another employer without his consent. This is in conformity with the provision Section 10 (1) of the Act which provides as follows

“The transfer of any contract from one employer to another shall be subject to the consent of the worker and the endorsement of the transfer upon the contract by an authorised labour officer”.

 

1.3.1  Employer

An employer is the person by whom the employee is or was employed. Rights can only be acquired against the one employed.  See the case of Harold Fielding Ltd. v. Mansi[8]

A person who exercises sufficient control over employee may be regarded as being the employer for some purposes as illustrated in the case of Road Transport Industry Training Board v. Ongaro[9]

 

1.3.2    Employee

According to Section 55 of the Trade Union Act 1974 defines an employee or worker as “any member of the public service of the federation or of a state or any individual (other than a member of any such public service) who has entered into or works under a contract with an employer.

In N.A.L.G.O. v. Bolton Corporation,[10] the House of Lords decided that an employee or worker includes manual labourers, clerks, apprentices, and persons in a contract personally to execute work or labour.

1.4     Independent Contractor

An independent contractor is an employee, employed by an employer to carry out a specific contract in the contract of employment.

According to Salmond in Nigeria Law Reform Act 1961, Section 7 (4) (b), that the liability of the independent contractor is not vicarious. A person is not generally liable for the tort of his independent contractor or the servant of such a contractor committed in the discharge of the contractual obligations.

1.5     Why an Employee Needs Protection?

A contract of employment like any other contract comes into existence by an agreement between the parties (i.e.) the employer and employee.

The agreement must be free and voluntary neither party compels the other to accept any terms or conditions in the agreement.

The vouched freedom and volunteerness of the agreement raised the inequality of bargaining power between the two parties. The number of people applying for work is too much for the number of jobs the employer have. Because of these factors, there is a brake down in the negotiation and the employer continues to negotiation until he gets what he considers favourable terms and conditions for the employment.

Technically, he agrees to the terms and conditions of the contract but in realization of this situation, Professor Adeogun made the following observation in line with the legal framework of Industrial relations in Nigeria[11] thus:

The resumption of equality between two parties tends to ignore other social and economic consideration which may make this equality and its underlying freedom, fictitious and hollow.  Indeed, the so-called bargaining power of the individual worker is important in practice, especially in a country like Nigeria where there are more workmen than the jobs available and where the employer can choose freely whom to employ[12]

 

1.6     Conclusion

          In conclusion of this chapter one, relating to contract of employment involving employers and employees relationship where one party made an offer and the other party accepts the offered, brought no doubt in negotiation where there is inequality bargain.

          Though it is a vouched freedom and volunteerness of the agreement that places the employee as a beggar without choice irrespective of the terms or conditions of the employment under which he accepted the offered. This is as a result of insufficient of availabilities of jobs in our society (Nigeria).

          The situation in Nigeria today as regard employment is such that it is difficult to get an employment and more difficult for wrongfully dismissed employee to secure an alternative employment.  Therefore, since the contracts of employment manifest from volunteers consent, which constitute a contract of service between the parties, the law is then in support of the party that is faithful to its bond under the contract and opposed the other that acts contrary to the provisions or contractual terms of the employment.



[1] Nigeria Labour Act Cap L1 LFN 2004.

[2] (1893) 1 QB 256.

[3] (1967) N.S.C.C. 158.

[4] Sagay, I.E., Nigerian Law of Contract. Ibadan: Spectrum, 1985, 59

[5] (1875) L.R. 10.

[6] (1923) 2 K.B. 261.

[7] Uvieghara, E.E., Labour Law in Nigeria. Lagos, Mathouse Press, 2001, 14-21.

[8] (1974) 1 RLR 79.

[9] (1943) A.C. 166.

[10] (1943) A.C. 166

[11] (1970) 3 NL. 13.

[12] Adeogun A.A., Termination of Contract of employment (A note on Nigeria Case Law) parts 1 and II Nigeria Journal of contemporary law (Vol. II) 1970.


WRONGFUL TERMINATION OF CONTRACTS OF EMPLOYMENT IN NIGERIA: A CASE FOR REINSTATEMENT OF PRIVATE EMPLOYEES


Download this Post in MS Word File Download this post in PDF File

Citation - Reference

All Project Materials Inc. (2020). WRONGFUL TERMINATION OF CONTRACTS OF EMPLOYMENT IN NIGERIA: A CASE FOR REINSTATEMENT OF PRIVATE EMPLOYEES. Available at: https://allprojectmaterials.com/department/paper-4355.html. [Accessed: ].

Download Complete Project Material

Search For more Project Topics

Search for more Project topics and Materials on this websites. There are numerous Project Topics, enter the topic and Click to Search.